Private Equity and Venture Capital in ESG Projects and Sustainability Investments: Challenges for Law Firms

Have you got a question?

Over the last few years, the world has witnessed a significant shift towards environmentally and socially responsible investing. Data from Natixis Investment Managers indicate that the percentage of institutional investors that choose to integrate ESG factors into investment decisions increased by 18% between 2019 and 2021 (McCahery, Pudschedl, Steindl, 2022). Private Equity (PE) and Venture Capital (VC) firms are increasingly focusing their investments on projects and technologies that promote sustainability and address pressing environmental and social challenges. This transition towards ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investing has profound implications not only for financial institutions but also for the legal firms that assist them in navigating this complex terrain. In this article, I explore the growing intersectionality between PE and VC in ESG projects and sustainability technology, the challenges faced by law firms, and the critical role of ethical values in aligning the interests of all stakeholders.

Private Equity and Venture Capital in ESG Projects

Private Equity and Venture Capital firms play a pivotal role in funding ESG projects and sustainability technology start-ups. For example, Tesla, Inc. (Electric Vehicle Manufacturer) is a well-known case of a company that received significant investment from both venture capital and private equity sources. VC funding was instrumental in its early stages, helping it develop cutting-edge electric vehicle technology. As the company matured, it attracted substantial investments from private equity firms. Tesla’s success not only represented a significant financial return for investors but also contributed to the promotion of sustainable transportation. Another example are financial instruments fostering increased investments in sustainable projects, such as the rise of Impact Investing Funds (IIF). Impact investing funds have gained traction in recent years, focused on making investments that generate both financial returns and positive social and environmental impact.

What is investing in ESG?

So, what makes investing in ESG interesting? On the one hand, ESG investing has been labelled as “woke capitalism” and decried in conservative political conversation as a dereliction of fiduciary duty (Moore, 2023). The problem with this narrative is that ESG considerations are different from, and sometimes antithetical to, notions of maximising profits and thus should not be considered by any responsible manager of investment money. On the other hand, ESG has been labelled as “greenwashing” and is described by more liberal experts in the field as an example of the finance industry trying to rebrand capitalism as ‘better for you, me, and the planet’ (Cort, 2023). These arguments belong to the idea that the finance industry is showcasing ESG to the public as a promise to save the world, when really the industry intends to continue its business-as-usual practice of maximising profits at the expense of society and the environment.

Labelled motivations aside, and for those new to the discussion, one can generally distinguish that PE firms typically invest in mature businesses with established revenue streams, while VC firms target start-ups with innovative solutions. Furthermore, research finds that PE firms use ESG factors more intensely than VC funds, regardless of geography (McCahery et al., 2023), outlining the increasingly global or transnational nature of ESG investments. Considering that VC funds are generally investing in early-stage and newer companies while PEs are engaged in enhancing value in more established companies, it is important to note that time horizons also play an important role in PE and VC investments. Investors with longer-term horizons statistically engage more with the ESG quality of companies in their portfolios (McCahery et al., 2023). Regardless of their investment focus, both types of firms have recognised the potential for substantial financial returns in ESG investments, driven both by increasing consumer demand for ethical products and regulatory pressures to reduce carbon footprints. These projects encompass a wide range of initiatives, from renewable energy and clean technology to social impact enterprises aimed at addressing inequality and poverty.

Numerous VC firms have for example supported green technology start-ups working on innovations in clean energy, waste reduction, and sustainable agriculture. All of these types of projects have longevity and sustainability at their centre, and investors are in it for the long-term. Funding mechanisms may change in the course of these initiatives, and they may attract increased PE backing when reaching maturity, but it is then a matter more of organising and managing the structure of the investments than of principle.

Given the complexity of this market, it comes as no surprise that in terms of numbers of different investment strategies under the umbrella of ESG investing, there are nearly an equal amount of ESG investment data sets available. The spectrum of strategies can, however, be defined. On one end we find “ESG integrated” investment strategies. These strategies look at ESG data sets that are financially material. That is, they recognise that certain ESG factors will be material to the financial performance of a company and therefore seek to understand the performance of the company on grounds of these factors to better project financial risk and opportunity. At the other end of the spectrum are investors that seek to maximise the environmental and social benefit created by the company even if it means sacrificing some level of financial return. In terms of scale, the ESG integrated investment strategy is most common.

In between these two strategies is a range that can best be defined based on the willingness to take a risk for potential financial gain. Because the relationship between ESG data sets and financial performance can be highly complex and bespoke, different investors will assess the financial materiality of ESG data in different ways (Cort, 2023). This builds particularly interesting cases for legal professionals involved in VC and PE-backed ESG investments in a number of areas.

Challenges for Law Firms giving advice

As PE and VC firms venture further into ESG and sustainability technology, they encounter various legal challenges, and law firms play a crucial role in addressing these issues. Some of the challenges firms face include regulatory complexity as ESG investing is subject to a complex set of regulations and reporting requirements. Law firms must stay up to date to ensure their clients remain compliant. On the other hand, the necessity for rigorous due diligence in assessing the environmental and social impact of potential investments is a complex task in itself. Conducting thorough due diligence to identify risks and opportunities in ESG projects and sustainability start-ups, especially in multinational transactions, can be a daunting task taking considerable time.

Once projects reach the contracting stage, drafting agreements that align with ESG goals and values is a unique challenge. In order to add value and lead to long-term success, contracts should include provisions related to sustainability performance, impact measurement, and exit strategies. Introducing strategic goals – even at a high level – facilitates mitigation of misunderstandings and fosters accountability among the parties, as well as enhances the management of expectations of all stakeholders.

Finally, ethical concerns will and have to take centre stage. Balancing financial returns with ethical values is at the heart of ESG investing. Law firms must help clients navigate the delicate balance between profit and purpose and will have to level up in order to be of value to their clients, also in terms of offering clients ethical business advice. The concept of ‘social ROI’ that is often applied to third sector work is something that deserves more attention in this context and helps in measuring impact and profitability, respectively profitability at what cost.

Ethical Values in the Intersection of VC, PE, and Law Firms

Ethical values are paramount in the intersection of VC, PE, and law firms. Aligning organisational values with those of their clients is essential for fostering trust and ensuring sustainable growth. VC and PE firms are increasingly recognising the importance of ethical investing. They are motivated by not only financial returns but also the positive impact their investments can have on society and the environment, with some firms even regarding it as an ‘ethical obligation’. Aligning their organisational values with ethical principles helps attract like-minded investors and partners who share their vision for a better and more sustainable world.

Law firms must, in turn, also define and uphold their ethical values when working with VC and PE clients. This involves ensuring that their legal advice and services align with the ethical standards of ESG investing overall. It means helping clients structure deals that promote sustainability, social responsibility, and good governance.

To take it a step further, law firms must go beyond aligning with their VC and PE clients’ values; they should also take into consideration aligning their own structures with the values of the companies benefiting from these investments. This alignment fosters trust among all parties involved, sends a powerful signal of responsibility to the law firm’s stakeholders, and is generally good business practice these days as it demonstrates a commitment to achieving meaningful ESG outcomes rather than merely ticking boxes for compliance and risking being caught for green-washing. This may involve some tough decisions along the way.

It is important to note that the landscape of ESG, sustainability, green technology, and investment in these areas is dynamic and constantly evolving. New projects and initiatives continue to emerge as more investors recognise the financial and societal benefits of sustainable investing.

Private Equity and Venture Capital firms are pivotal players in the growing field of ESG projects and sustainability technology. As they navigate the complex landscape of ethical investing, law firms play an essential role in providing legal expertise, addressing regulatory challenges, and helping clients align their values with their investments. Ethical values are at the core of this intersection, guiding VC and PE firms, as well as the law firms that serve them, in their pursuit of financial success intertwined with positive environmental and social impact. By embracing and upholding these values, all stakeholders can contribute to a more sustainable and responsible future.

When it comes to getting advice on ESG investments and sustainable strategies, having a dedicated and experienced commercial team is paramount. At Oracle Solicitor, ESG is not just a buzzword; it’s an integral part of our ethos. With our commitment to upholding regulatory compliance, our extensive knowledge in commercial aspects, and an approach that considers all elements of ESG, we are well-equipped to guide companies with their legal considerations. We are dedicated to providing informed and insightful advice, helping our clients make a positive impact while safeguarding their financial interests and reputation. Get in touch with our commercial team today and book an appointment to speak to one of our experts.